Skip to main content
Have Faith Trees — tree service in St. Augustine, FL

Storm Response

What to Do With a Storm-Damaged Tree

Not every damaged tree needs to come out, and not every intact-looking tree is fine. Here is how to walk your property after a storm and read what you are seeing.

Have Faith Trees6 min read

Oak with a split union and torn limb after a Florida storm being assessed by an arborist

Short answer

Check the ground at the base of every large tree first — cracked or heaved soil means the root plate has moved and the tree is failing regardless of how the canopy looks. Then look up for hangers. A tree that has lost more than half its canopy is usually not worth saving.

After a storm passes, most people look at the obvious damage — the limb on the driveway, the tree across the fence — and miss the trees that are quietly more dangerous.

This is the walk-through we do on a property after a weather event, and what each finding actually means.

Start with what is over your head

Hangers are the first priority: broken limbs caught in the canopy, still suspended. These are called widow-makers for a reason. They come down without any wind at all, on their own schedule, and they are the leading cause of post-storm injuries to homeowners.

Look up over every place people spend time — driveways, walkways, patios, play areas, where the car parks. If there is a hanger above any of them, stay out of that area and get it removed professionally. Do not throw a rope over it and pull.

Check the ground at the base of every large tree

This is the check almost nobody does and the one that finds the most dangerous trees.

Walk to the base of each significant tree and look at the soil. Cracked, heaved, or mounded soil on one side — usually the side opposite any lean — means the root plate has moved. A tree with a moved root plate is actively failing regardless of how healthy the canopy looks, and it will not recover its anchorage.

Also check whether a tree leans more than it used to. Photographs from before the storm help enormously here, which is one reason we tell people to photograph their property in May.

Reading the damage: what can be saved

Not every damaged tree is finished. The distinction comes down to how much healthy structure remains.

  • A few broken branches, canopy mostly intact: almost always saveable. Clean cuts back to sound wood, and the tree recovers.
  • One large limb torn out, leaving a wound on the trunk: usually saveable, depending on the size of the wound relative to the trunk. Proper cutting back to the branch collar limits decay.
  • Split at a codominant union, both halves alive, wood around the union still sound: potentially saveable with cabling and bracing plus weight reduction. Needs prompt assessment — the longer it sits, the more the split works.
  • More than half the canopy lost: usually not worth saving. The tree cannot photosynthesize enough to sustain itself and will decline over several years while becoming a hazard.
  • Trunk snapped or split deep into the stem: not saveable. Remove it.
  • Uprooted, even partially: not saveable. Once anchorage is gone it does not come back, and "standing it back up" does not work on a mature tree.

The trees that fail later

The most useful thing about a post-storm walk is finding the damage that has not caused a problem yet.

Torn limb attachments that are still hanging on. Cracks in unions that have not opened fully. Root damage from soil movement that has not translated into a lean yet. Bark torn away from a section of trunk. All of these are failures in progress, and all of them are far cheaper to address now than after the next system.

Also pay attention to trees that were suddenly exposed. If a storm took down the trees that were sheltering yours, the survivors are now bearing wind loads they have never experienced, and they are disproportionately likely to fail next time.

What not to do

Do not top a damaged tree to "even it out." A tree that lost limbs on one side is not helped by removing the healthy ones on the other. Corrective reduction over a couple of seasons is the right approach.

Do not paint or seal wounds. Wound dressings trap moisture and interfere with the tree’s natural compartmentalization process. A clean cut is the treatment.

Do not fertilize a storm-damaged tree immediately. A stressed tree does not need to be pushed into growth it cannot support. Water and time are more useful.

And do not cut anything under tension yourself. Storm-loaded wood moves when it is cut, and that is where the serious injuries happen. Our emergency tree service handles that work with the rigging it requires.

Documentation, while it is fresh

Photograph everything before it is cleaned up, whether or not you plan to file a claim. Include the failure point on any tree that came down, the damage to structures, and the overall scene.

If a tree hit a structure, keep the emergency make-safe work itemized separately from the full cleanup on your invoice — carriers frequently treat them differently. Our guide on what to do when a tree falls on your house covers the claim process in more detail.

Frequently asked questions

Can a split tree be saved?
Sometimes. If the split is recent, both halves are alive, and the wood around the union is sound, a brace-and-cable system with weight reduction can save it. If the union is decayed or the split runs deep into the trunk, it cannot.
How much canopy loss can a tree survive?
As a rough guide, a tree that has lost more than half its canopy is unlikely to be worth saving. Below that, most healthy trees recover with proper corrective pruning over a season or two.
Should I have my trees checked even if nothing fell?
Yes, particularly after a significant event. The failures that matter most are often the ones still standing — moved root plates, cracked unions, and torn attachments that have not let go yet.

The bottom line

Walk the property, look up, look at the ground at the base of every big tree, and get anything ambiguous assessed before you park under it again.

We take post-storm assessment calls across St. Augustine, St. Johns County and Flagler County, and we will tell you which trees are genuinely finished and which ones just need cleaning up.

Want a real answer about your specific tree?

Call +1 (208) 635-2100 for a free on-site estimate across St. Augustine and St. Johns County. We will tell you plainly what it needs — including when the answer is nothing.

  • 47 five-star reviews
  • Licensed & insured
  • 24/7 storm response

Services mentioned here

Local to your area

Call NowFree Quote

47 five-star reviews · Licensed & insured · Free estimates